AKQJ9
5432
-
A432
S W N E
P P 1S 2H
3D X ?
(no alerts, no explanations, so far, anyway)
--
The book "1984" used to be a cautionary tale;
Now it is a "how-to" manual.
I am curious to see how experts will answer this, but with none forthcoming, I'll take a stab!
It appears to me that hands can be constructed for partner making any of 3D, 3H, 3S, 3NT or 4C
the best contract!
Most of those are long-shots we'd be unlikely to achieve even when correct. But Redouble,
surely for take-out, gives us a chance to get to our best spot. Or would the unilateral 3 Spades
be better, since this is likely best no matter how few spades partner has? Pass could be best;
especially if East, somehow thinking the Double responsive, might rescue us!
Why didn't partner open 3 Diamonds, or a weak 2 Diamonds? (Because he has four hearts?)
He didn't make a Negative Double so he has little help for black suits, but are his diamonds
AQT98x or AQ8xxx ?
Summary: I don't know. I'm considering an epileptic fit to let a substitute figure it out.
Cheers,
James